
Annuities grow tax-deferred, so you owe nothing while the money sits inside the contract. Taxes arrive when you take withdrawals, and how much you owe depends on whether the annuity is qualified (funded with pre-tax dollars) or nonqualified (funded with after-tax dollars). Qualified withdrawals count as fully taxable ordinary income, while nonqualified withdrawals tax earnings first, under a rule called LIFO, before your original principal comes out tax-free.
TL;DR:
- Annuitized payments use an exclusion ratio to split each check between tax free principal and taxable earnings; after you recover your basis, every payment is taxable.
- Withdrawals before age 59½ generally incur a 10% additional federal tax on the taxable amount, but death, disability, and qualifying annuitized payments qualify for exceptions.
- A Section 1035 exchange avoids current tax only when carriers transfer funds directly; receiving the money yourself can make the transaction taxable.
- Most states tax annuity withdrawals as ordinary income, but nine have no personal income tax, and nonqualified earnings may face NIIT above income thresholds.
- Keep records of contributions made after paying tax to support your basis, and spread withdrawals across tax years to manage brackets and NIIT exposure.
Table of Contents
- Qualified vs. nonqualified annuities: what is taxed and why
- How withdrawals, annuitization, and the exclusion ratio work
- Early withdrawals, penalties, and exceptions
- Section 1035 exchanges and rollovers: moving contracts without tax now
- State tax and Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) considerations
- Reporting, withholding, and forms you’ll see (1099-R, W-4P, Form 5329)
- Practical tax planning steps
- A planner’s perspective on annuity taxes
- How Green Insurance can help plan annuity taxes and retirement income
- FAQ
- Sources
Qualified vs. nonqualified annuities: what is taxed and why
A qualified annuity is funded with pre-tax money, usually inside an IRA or an employer plan like a 401(k). Because you never paid tax on those contributions, the IRS taxes the entire withdrawal as ordinary income. A nonqualified annuity is funded with money you already paid taxes on, which changes the math entirely.
For nonqualified contracts, the IRS treats earnings as the first dollars out, a method known as last-in, first-out (LIFO). That means your gains get taxed before you ever touch the principal you contributed. Once you have withdrawn all the growth, remaining withdrawals of your original investment come out tax-free, since you already paid tax on that money once.
A few points worth keeping straight:
- Qualified annuities: pre-tax contributions, 100% of each withdrawal is taxable.
- Nonqualified annuities: after-tax contributions, earnings are taxed first under LIFO, then principal returns tax-free.
- Mixed-source annuities (part pre-tax, part after-tax) require tracking each portion separately for accurate reporting.
Contracts issued before August 1982 sometimes follow different ordering rules for withdrawals under grandfathered provisions, so older policies deserve a closer look at the original paperwork or a conversation with the carrier before assuming standard LIFO treatment applies.
How withdrawals, annuitization, and the exclusion ratio work
Not every withdrawal gets taxed the same way. A lump-sum or partial withdrawal from a nonqualified annuity follows the LIFO rule described above. Annuitized payments, meaning you convert the contract into a stream of income payments, work differently because each payment blends a return of principal with taxable earnings.
Here is how that blended treatment gets calculated:
- The insurer calculates an exclusion ratio, which determines what portion of each periodic payment is a tax-free return of your investment and what portion is taxable earnings.
- Most contracts use the Simplified Method to compute this ratio, while certain older contracts use the General Rule instead.
- The exclusion ratio applies consistently to each payment until your cost basis is fully recovered, after which the full payment becomes taxable.
- Insurers typically calculate these figures for you and report the taxable amount directly on your Form 1099-R, so you are not left doing the math alone.
Withholding on periodic annuity payments generally works like wage withholding by default, pulling tax from the taxable portion only, not the tax-free return of principal. That taxable slice is ordinary income, taxed at your regular marginal rate rather than any preferential capital gains rate, regardless of how long the contract has grown.
Early withdrawals, penalties, and exceptions
Taking money out before age 59½ usually triggers a 10% additional federal tax on the taxable portion of the withdrawal, on top of ordinary income tax.
Several exceptions can waive that extra 10%:
- Distributions made after the owner’s death.
- Distributions tied to total and permanent disability.
- Distributions received as part of a qualifying annuitized payment stream.
The distribution code in Box 7 of your Form 1099-R tells the IRS which category applies, and it directly affects whether you need to file Form 5329 to claim an exception. Separately, surrender charges your carrier may apply for early withdrawals are contractual fees, not IRS penalties, and the two should never be confused when estimating total cost.
Section 1035 exchanges and rollovers: moving contracts without tax now
A Section 1035 exchange lets you swap one annuity contract for another without triggering current tax, as long as the transfer moves directly from one carrier to another. The moment you receive the funds personally, even briefly before repurchasing a new contract, the IRS generally treats it as a taxable event.
A few things to watch:
- Insist on a direct, carrier-to-carrier transfer rather than a check made out to you.
- For partial exchanges, basis gets allocated proportionally between the old and new contracts, which requires accurate recordkeeping.
- Keep copies of exchange paperwork and carrier correspondence in case the IRS questions the transaction later.
Pro Tip: Ask both carriers to confirm in writing that the exchange qualifies under Section 1035 before signing anything.
Readers exploring how laddering multiple contracts can build a steadier income floor may find our annuity ladder strategy using §1035 exchanges useful for seeing how the mechanics play out in practice.
State tax and Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) considerations
Most states tax annuity withdrawals as ordinary income, matching the federal treatment, though nine states currently levy no personal income tax at all. Where you live at the time of withdrawal can shift your total tax bill meaningfully, even when the federal rules stay identical.
- Nonqualified annuity income can count toward net investment income for purposes of the Net Investment Income Tax, reported on Form 8960.
- NIIT applies on top of ordinary income tax when your modified adjusted gross income crosses certain thresholds.
- State rules vary enough that checking your own state’s retirement-income provisions, or talking with a planner familiar with your state, is worth the time before assuming federal treatment is the whole picture.
Reporting, withholding, and forms you’ll see (1099-R, W-4P, Form 5329)
Expect a handful of recurring forms each tax season once annuity withdrawals begin.
- Form 1099-R reports your distribution, and the distribution code in Box 7 tells you and the IRS what type of withdrawal occurred.
- Form W-4P lets you set your withholding preference for periodic payments, or in some cases opt out of withholding entirely if you qualify.
- Form 5329 is used to report the 10% additional tax on early distributions when it is not already accounted for elsewhere, while in other cases the tax flows through Schedule 2.
- Payers generally withhold as if the taxable portion were wages unless you submit different instructions on Form W-4P.
Keeping these three forms organized each year makes tax filing far less stressful, especially once multiple income sources start arriving around the same time.
Practical tax planning steps
A few habits make annuity taxation far easier to manage. Keep a permanent record of your purchase date and every after-tax contribution, since that documentation supports your basis calculation years later when memories fade and paperwork gets harder to track down. Spread withdrawals across tax years when possible, which helps manage your marginal bracket and reduces the chance of tripping NIIT thresholds in any single year.
When moving money between contracts, use a Section 1035 exchange and insist on a direct carrier-to-carrier transfer to avoid an accidental taxable event. Annuity income also interacts with Social Security taxation, required minimum distributions, and Medicare premium calculations, so timing withdrawals around those milestones matters.
Pro Tip: Review your withdrawal schedule every year, not just once at retirement, since tax brackets and NIIT thresholds shift and your optimal strategy can shift with them.
For readers who want a second set of eyes on how annuity withdrawals fit alongside Medicare and Social Security timing, personalized retirement income planning support is available locally.

A planner’s perspective on annuity taxes
Working through these rules with clients, the biggest surprise is rarely the tax rate itself. It is how much documentation and timing change the outcome. Two people with identical contracts can owe very different amounts depending on when they withdraw and how well they tracked their basis. Complex situations, especially inherited contracts, deserve a tailored review rather than guesswork.
— Zach
How Green Insurance can help plan annuity taxes and retirement income
Annuity tax rules get complicated fast once you factor in withdrawal timing, exclusion ratios, and how that income interacts with Medicare premiums. We built our approach around walking through those details with clients directly, rather than leaving you to piece together IRS worksheets alone.

Our certified Medicare Insurance Planners® offer retirement income planning alongside our core Medicare enrollment and plan comparison services, so annuity timing decisions get weighed against your broader coverage picture, not in isolation. We have built our reputation on more than 625 client reviews and recognition as a top-rated local agency, with the same hands-on support continuing years after your initial consultation.
If you want help thinking through annuity withdrawals, Section 1035 exchanges, or how retirement income timing affects your Medicare costs, explore our annuities page or schedule a consultation through our services page to get started.
This article is general information, not a substitute for advice from a qualified financial advisor. Consult a qualified financial professional about your own circumstances before acting on anything here.

FAQ
Do I have to pay federal taxes on an annuity?
Yes, in most cases. Qualified annuities are fully taxable as ordinary income when withdrawn, while nonqualified annuities tax only the earnings portion first under the IRS’s LIFO rule, with principal returning tax-free afterward.
What does Warren Buffett say about annuities?
This article does not cover specific commentary from Warren Buffett on annuities, and no verified source ties a definitive position to him on this topic. For personal retirement income decisions, reviewing your own contract terms and tax situation with a licensed planner is more useful than relying on any single public figure’s opinion.
How much will a $100,000 annuity pay out per month?
Payout amounts depend on factors like your age, the contract’s interest rate, payout option chosen, and whether payments are guaranteed for life or a fixed period, so there is no single universal figure. An insurance carrier or licensed planner can run an illustration based on your specific contract terms to give you an accurate estimate.
What are the downsides of having an annuity?
Annuities can involve surrender charges for early withdrawals, and nonqualified annuity earnings are taxed as ordinary income rather than at lower capital gains rates. Reviewing your full contract terms and comparing them against your retirement timeline with a planner helps you weigh these factors before purchasing.

