
Guaranteed issue rights are your right to buy certain Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policies in limited situations, even if you have health conditions, and the insurance company cannot turn you down or charge you more because of your health. Medicare describes them as rights to buy certain Medigap policies outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period. The most common reasons people use them: leaving a Medicare Advantage plan, losing employer coverage, or using a “trial right” in the first year after a switch. The deadlines are short, so the order of your steps matters.
TL;DR
- Guaranteed issue rights let you buy certain Medigap policies with no health-based denial, but only in specific situations and within a fixed window.
- The usual window is 63 days after your old coverage ends. You can apply up to 60 days before it ends, so there is no gap.
- Two trial rights exist for people who try Medicare Advantage: one if you joined at 65, and one if you dropped a Medigap policy to join for the first time. Both are tied to your first year in the plan.
- Keep every notice about your coverage ending. It is your proof when you apply.
- Do not cancel your Medicare Advantage plan until your Medigap application is approved and has a start date.
Table of Contents
- What a guaranteed issue right actually protects
- The situations that trigger a right
- Medicare trial rights: the 12-month safety net
- Which Medigap plans you can buy under a right
- Deadlines and application steps
- Leaving Medicare Advantage: when and how
- Three worked examples
- State rules can give you more
- Perspective: what we see at the kitchen table
- Get a second set of eyes before the deadline
- Switching Medigap plans is a different question
- FAQ
- Sources
What a guaranteed issue right actually protects
Most people buy a Medigap policy during the Medigap Open Enrollment Period, the six months that start when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. Outside that window, an insurer in most states can ask health questions and decline you or charge more. A guaranteed issue right is an exception that reopens the door for a specific reason.
When you have the right, the insurer:
- must sell you the policy,
- must cover your pre-existing conditions, and
- cannot charge you more because of your health.
The insurer may still set a waiting period for pre-existing conditions in some cases. Medicare notes that prior creditable coverage or a guaranteed issue right can avoid or shorten that waiting period in many situations, so ask about it before you apply.
Notice what the right does not do. It does not guarantee the lowest price, and it does not let you pick any plan letter you like. The plans you may buy depend on your situation, which we cover below.
The situations that trigger a right
Medicare’s own guide lists the situations in detail, and it is worth reading the section that matches your case in Choosing a Medigap Policy. In plain words, they fall into a few groups.
You are in a Medicare Advantage plan that ends or changes
This is the group most of our clients ask about. Typical triggers include your plan leaving Medicare, your plan stopping service in your area, you moving out of the plan’s service area, or the plan breaking its contract with you. In these cases your right starts when the plan coverage is about to end.
You have other coverage that is ending
If you had employer or union group health coverage that pays after Medicare, and that coverage ends, you may have a right. The same can apply when certain other supplemental coverage stops. The trigger is that the coverage ends, not that you quit it by choice in most cases, so confirm the details for your plan before you act.
You are using a trial right
Trial rights are the ones people search for as the “Medicare Advantage trial right.” They deserve their own section, so see the next one.
Your Medigap insurer leaves you
If your Medigap company goes bankrupt, or misled you, or the coverage otherwise ends through no fault of yours, you may qualify for a new guaranteed issue right.
Medicare trial rights: the 12-month safety net
There are two distinct trial rights. People mix them up, and the difference changes which policies you can buy.
| Trial right 1 | Trial right 2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Who it is for | You joined a Medicare Advantage plan when you were first eligible for Part A at 65 | You dropped a Medigap policy to join Medicare Advantage for the first time |
| Time limit | You decide within the first year to return to Original Medicare | You have been in the plan less than a year |
| What you can buy | Any Medigap policy sold in your state by any insurer | Your old policy back if the same company still sells it. Otherwise, certain policies depending on state law |
Both details come from Medicare’s guidance: the first right applies if you joined at 65 and decide within the first year to go back, and the second lets you get your former policy back if the same company still sells it. Our guide to how the 12-month Medigap window works walks through examples of both.
A common surprise: if you are 66 or older and joined Medicare Advantage after already being on Original Medicare with no Medigap, you usually do not have a trial right. That case is where health questions come back, and where a bad timing decision gets expensive.
Which Medigap plans you can buy under a right
The plan letters available depend on the situation. Medicare’s guide says that, depending on the right, you may buy Plans A, B, C, D, F, or G, with limits on C and F, or any Medigap policy sold in your state under the first-year trial right. Plan C and Plan F limits exist because those plans are generally not sold to people who became newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.
For most people, then, Plan G is the practical comprehensive option. If you want to compare plan letters against what you actually use, see our overview of Medicare Supplement plans.
Deadlines and application steps
The clock is the most unforgiving part of this topic. Medicare’s guide says to apply 60 days before or within 63 days after your coverage ends in the common situations. A few rules of thumb:
- Find your end date. Look at the notice from your plan or employer. If you are leaving by choice, you control the date.
- Apply before coverage ends if you can. Medicare says you can apply for a Medigap policy before your Medicare Advantage coverage ends and ask for it to start when that coverage ends, so you have continuous coverage.
- Wait for approval. Do not disenroll from your current plan until the Medigap company confirms the policy and start date in writing.
- Keep proof. Save letters, notices, emails, and claim denials. Medicare advises keeping any proof that your coverage ended in case the insurer asks.
- Mention the right on the application. Say which situation applies and attach proof.
Why you cannot overlap the two
It is illegal for an insurer to sell you a Medigap policy if you remain enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. Federal rules treat this as an anti-duplication requirement: a new Medigap policy generally cannot be issued before other coverage ends. In practice, the Medigap policy starts the day the Advantage plan ends, and the two are lined up through the application date rather than a double enrollment.
Federal law also sets no specific time limit on how fast an insurer processes an application, though states may. That is one more reason to apply early inside your window rather than on day 60.
Leaving Medicare Advantage: when and how
Guaranteed issue rights answer “can I buy Medigap?” You also need to know how to leave the plan itself. Two common ways:
- Annual Enrollment Period (October 15 to December 7). If you do not pick another Advantage plan during this period, Medicare will automatically enroll you in Original Medicare once your plan ends. Our page on Medicare Advantage enrollment deadlines covers the December cutoff and the March switch.
- Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment (January 1 to March 31). If you are in an Advantage plan, you can drop it and return to Original Medicare in this window.
Here is the catch that trips people up. Leaving Medicare Advantage does not by itself give you a guaranteed issue right. If you leave during these periods and you have no trial right and no other qualifying situation, a Medigap insurer in most states can use health questions. Many people go back to Original Medicare, apply for Medigap, and get declined after a diagnosis. Check your right first, then leave the plan. Our article on going back to a Medicare Supplement after Medicare Advantage covers this scenario in more depth.
Three worked examples
Maria, 66, joined Medicare Advantage at 65. She finds her specialists are out of network. She is within her first year, so she is inside the first trial right. She may buy any Medigap policy sold in her state, with no health questions. She applies for Plan G, gets a start date, then disenrolls.
James, 70, dropped his Medigap Plan N last spring to try an Advantage plan with a zero premium. He has been in the plan less than a year. Under the second trial right, he can ask his old company to take him back if it still sells that policy. If it does not, he may buy certain other policies depending on state law.
Linda, 68, left a $0 premium plan during the Open Enrollment window and then was diagnosed with a heart condition. She had no trial right. Her Medigap application can be reviewed with health questions in most states, and it may be declined. She stays in Original Medicare with no supplement, or picks another Advantage plan. This is the outcome the rules are designed to prevent when you plan ahead.
These are illustrative scenarios, not real clients, and your own facts could change the answer.

State rules can give you more
Federal rights are the floor. Some states add more. Medicare notes that Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Wisconsin have guaranteed issue rights but structure their Medigap policies differently, and that you may have additional rights under state law. The agency tells readers to contact their State Insurance Department to learn what applies to them.
Some states also allow people under 65 who are on Medicare to buy Medigap. If that is your situation, see our page on Medigap for people under 65.
If you live in Florida, where we work, call the State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) or the Florida Department of Financial Services, or ask us to check the rule against your dates before you apply.
Perspective: what we see at the kitchen table
In our Orange Park and Fleming Island offices, the costly mistakes with guaranteed issue rights are almost never about the law. They are about order. Someone cancels the Advantage plan on a Friday, then calls us Monday to find the Medigap application cannot start without a gap, or never qualified at all.

Our advice is simple. First, pin down which right you have, if any, and write the end date on a calendar. Second, apply for the policy before you leave anything. Third, compare the plan letters against your doctors and prescriptions, not just the monthly premium. We do this for free, because carriers pay us when you enroll, and you are never asked to pay for the consultation. We also stay in touch afterward, because the right decision at 66 may need a second look at 70.
The worst cases are the ones where a trial right was available and nobody mentioned it. If you are in your first year in a Medicare Advantage plan, that is the moment to ask, not later.
— Zach
Get a second set of eyes before the deadline
If you think you have a guaranteed issue right, or you are not sure, our certified Medicare Insurance Planners can check your dates and compare the Medigap policies available to you across carriers. Start with our Medicare enrollment assistance, or look at the Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans we offer. There is no charge for the consultation.
Switching Medigap plans is a different question
Guaranteed issue rights do not usually cover switching from one Medigap policy to another when nothing has gone wrong. If you simply want a better price, insurers can often ask health questions, though some states have extra rules. See our guide on switching Medigap plans without losing coverage before you cancel a policy that works.
FAQ
Do guaranteed issue rights expire?
Yes. The right is tied to a window, usually 63 days after your previous coverage ends, and the trial rights are tied to your first year in a plan. Miss the window and an insurer may use health questions in most states.
Can I use a guaranteed issue right to go back to Original Medicare and buy any plan?
Not always. The plans you can buy depend on your right. Under the first-year trial right you may buy any Medigap policy sold in your state. In other situations the choice is limited to certain plans, such as A, B, C, D, F, or G, with limits on C and F.
Is the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period a guaranteed issue right?
No. It lets you leave your Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare between January 1 and March 31, but it does not guarantee that a Medigap company will accept you. Check whether a trial right applies before you use it.
What proof will the insurer want?
Keep any letter, notice, email, or claim denial showing your coverage ended or is ending. Medicare suggests saving these documents so you can show your coverage ended.
Who can help me confirm my rights?
Your State Insurance Department and your state’s SHIP counselors can tell you what applies where you live. A licensed Medicare agent can also check your dates and compare policies at no cost to you.
Sources
- Choosing a Medigap Policy, Medicare.gov
- Learn How Medigap Works, Medicare.gov
- When can I buy a Medigap policy? Medicare.gov
- Guaranteed issue rights, Medicare.gov
- Program Memorandum on Medigap, CMS

