Skip to main content
    5/5 (600+ Google Reviews)Certified Medicare Insurance Planner®
    Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F: Which Medigap Option Fits Your Costs and Eligibility?
    Back to Blog
    Medicare Guide
    June 26, 2026

    Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F: Which Medigap Option Fits Your Costs and Eligibility?

    If you are comparing medicare supplement plan g vs plan f, the decision usually comes down to one question: is Plan F’s extra coverage worth its premium, or does Plan G offer better long-term value? Both are standardized Medigap options used with Original Medicare, but eligibility rules and the Medicare Part B deductible make the choice more nuanced than it first appears.

    What is the main difference in medicare supplement plan g vs plan f?

    The biggest difference between Plan F and Plan G is simple: Plan F covers the Medicare Part B deductible, while Plan G does not. After you pay the annual Part B deductible, Plan G generally covers the same Medicare-approved cost-sharing categories as Plan F.

    According to Medicare.gov, Medigap policies are standardized in most states, meaning a Plan G from one insurance company must provide the same basic medical benefits as a Plan G from another company. The same standardization applies to Plan F, although premiums, underwriting rules, household discounts, and customer service can vary by insurance company.

    In practical terms, Plan F may feel more “complete” because it can cover the Part B deductible. But many clients find that Plan G’s lower premium can offset the deductible difference, depending on their ZIP code, age, tobacco status, household eligibility, and carrier pricing.

    a retired couple sitting at a kitchen table comparing Medicare documents with a calculator and prescription bottles nearby
    a retired couple sitting at a kitchen table comparing Medicare documents with a calculator and prescription bottles nearby

    How do Plan F and Plan G work with Original Medicare?

    Plan F and Plan G are forms of Medicare supplement insurance, also called Medigap. They are designed to help pay certain out-of-pocket expense amounts left after Original Medicare pays its approved share.

    Original Medicare includes Medicare Part A for hospital insurance and Medicare Part B for medical insurance. A Medigap plan does not replace Original Medicare; it works alongside it to help with deductibles, co-insurance, and copayments.

    For example, if you visit a doctor who accepts Medicare assignment, Medicare Part B typically pays its approved portion after the deductible is met. Then your Medigap Plan may help pay the remaining Medicare-approved co-insurance, depending on the plan letter.

    Plan F and Plan G are not the same as Medicare Advantage. A Medicare Advantage plan is an alternative way to receive Medicare benefits through a private insurer, often with provider networks and plan-specific rules. A Medigap policy is used with Original Medicare, and you generally cannot use Medigap to pay Medicare Advantage cost-sharing.

    Who can buy Plan F, and who is limited to Plan G?

    Eligibility is one of the most important parts of the medicare supplement plan g vs plan f comparison. Under federal law changes connected to the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015, newly eligible Medicare beneficiaries can no longer buy Medigap plans that cover the Medicare Part B deductible.

    That rule affects Plan F and Plan C. If you became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, you generally cannot buy Plan F or Plan C. In that situation, Plan G is often the closest broad-coverage alternative.

    If you were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020, you may be able to keep Plan F if you already have it. You may also be able to apply for Medicare Plan F if an insurance company offers it in your state, although medical underwriting may apply outside certain guaranteed issue situations.

    In everyday client conversations, this eligibility issue often settles the question quickly. Someone newly eligible for Medicare typically compares Plan G with Plan N or other available Medigap policies, while someone already enrolled in Plan F may compare premiums to decide whether switching to Plan G is worth considering.

    What does Plan F cover that Plan G does not?

    Plan F covers the standardized Medigap benefit categories available under federal rules, including the Medicare Part B deductible. That is the one benefit category Plan G does not cover.

    Based on Medicare.gov’s Medigap benefit comparison, Plan F covers many major Original Medicare cost-sharing areas, including:

    • Medicare Part A hospital coinsurance and hospital costs up to an additional 365 days after Medicare benefits are used
    • Medicare Part B coinsurance or copayment
    • Blood, generally the first 3 pints
    • Part A hospice care coinsurance or copayment
    • Skilled nursing facility care coinsurance
    • Medicare Part A deductible
    • Medicare Part B deductible
    • Medicare Part B excess charges
    • Foreign travel emergency coverage, up to plan limits

    Because Plan F covers the Medicare Part B deductible, some beneficiaries like the predictability. They may prefer paying a higher premium if it reduces the chance of receiving small Medicare-approved bills during the year.

    However, “more coverage” is not always the same as “better value.” If the annual premium difference between Plan F and Plan G is greater than the Part B deductible, Plan G may be the more cost-efficient choice, assuming the benefits otherwise fit the person’s needs.

    What does Plan G cover after the Part B deductible?

    Plan G cover is broad, but it does not pay the annual Part B deductible. Once you meet that deductible, Plan G generally pays the same standardized Medicare-approved cost-sharing categories that Plan F pays.

    This is why Medicare Plan G is one of the most commonly discussed Medigap options for people who became eligible for Medicare after 2019. It offers strong protection against many Original Medicare cost gaps without violating the rule that new Medicare beneficiaries cannot buy plans that cover the Medicare Part B deductible.

    For a real-world example, imagine a Medicare beneficiary in Orange Park who sees several specialists during the year. With Plan G, they would be responsible for the Part B deductible first, then the plan may help cover Medicare-approved Part B coinsurance after that point.

    This structure can appeal to people who want broad provider flexibility under Original Medicare and are comfortable paying one predictable deductible amount each year. The deductible amount is set annually by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, so it should be checked each year during coverage reviews.

    a local insurance advisor pointing to a printed Medigap comparison chart during a consultation with a senior client
    a local insurance advisor pointing to a printed Medigap comparison chart during a consultation with a senior client

    Is Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F mostly a premium decision?

    Premium is a major factor, but it should not be the only factor. The best comparison looks at annual total cost, not just the monthly price.

    When practitioners compare Plan F and Plan G with clients, they usually look at:

    • The monthly premium for Plan F
    • The monthly premium for Plan G
    • The annual Medicare Part B deductible
    • Household discounts, if available
    • Rate increase history, when available from carriers
    • Medical underwriting risk if switching plans
    • Whether the client values convenience over potential savings

    For example, if Plan F costs significantly more per year than Plan G, the extra premium may exceed the deductible that Plan F covers. In that case, paying the Part B deductible under Plan G could still leave the beneficiary ahead financially.

    On the other hand, if Plan F and Plan G premiums are very close, a person already eligible for Plan F may reasonably prefer Plan F’s fuller first-dollar coverage. This is why a personalized quote matters more than a generic national comparison.

    Can you switch from Plan F to Plan G?

    Many beneficiaries with Medicare Plan F ask whether they should switch to Plan G to lower premiums. The answer depends on state rules, timing, health history, and whether the new carrier requires medical underwriting.

    Your Medigap open enrollment period generally starts when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B, and it lasts for six months. During that time, federal rules give strong protections for buying a Medigap policy without medical underwriting.

    After that window, switching Medigap policies often requires answering health questions unless you qualify for a guaranteed issue right. Medicare.gov explains that guaranteed issue rights can apply in specific situations, such as losing certain coverage through no fault of your own.

    For Florida residents, this makes it important not to cancel an existing Plan F before the new Medigap Plan is approved and you understand the effective date. A licensed insurance professional can help sequence the application properly so there is no accidental coverage gap.

    How do high-deductible Plan F and high-deductible Plan G compare?

    In some states, Plans F and G also offer high-deductible versions. These plans require you to pay Medicare-covered costs up to a deductible amount before the Medigap plan begins paying covered benefits.

    High-deductible Plan F is subject to the same eligibility restriction as regular Plan F. If you became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, you generally cannot buy high-deductible Plan F.

    High-deductible Plan G may be available to new Medicare beneficiaries in some markets. It can offer a lower monthly premium, but the tradeoff is a higher potential out-of-pocket expense before Medigap benefits begin.

    This type of Medicare supplement plan is usually best evaluated with careful budgeting. It may fit someone who wants catastrophic-style Medigap protection and can comfortably handle the deductible exposure, but it may not fit someone who needs more predictable medical expenses.

    Do Plan F and Plan G include prescription drug, dental, or vision coverage?

    Modern Medigap policies, including Plan F and Plan G, do not include outpatient prescription drug coverage. If you want prescription coverage with Original Medicare and a Medigap policy, you typically need a separate Medicare Part D drug plan.

    This is an important difference from some Medicare Advantage plans, which may include drug coverage and extra benefits. With Original Medicare plus Medigap, the structure is usually more modular: Medicare Part A and Part B, a Medigap plan, and a standalone Part D plan.

    Plan F and Plan G also do not generally include routine dental, vision, or hearing benefits. Some insurance companies may offer separate dental, vision, life, or final expense policies, but those are separate products and should be evaluated on their own terms.

    Caregivers helping a parent compare coverage should pay close attention to this point. A parent may be satisfied with Plan G for medical cost-sharing but still need a drug plan that covers specific medications at preferred pharmacies.

    an adult daughter helping her elderly father review Medicare prescription drug information on a laptop at home
    an adult daughter helping her elderly father review Medicare prescription drug information on a laptop at home

    How should Florida residents compare Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F?

    Florida retirees often compare Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F because provider flexibility, seasonal travel, and predictable costs matter. Original Medicare with a Medigap plan can be attractive for people who want access to Medicare-participating providers without a Medicare Advantage network.

    Still, premiums can vary by county, ZIP code, age, tobacco use, gender, and insurance company rating method. A Plan G in Orange Park may be priced differently from a similar plan in another Florida community, even though the standardized benefits are the same.

    The National Association of Insurance Commissioners notes in its consumer guidance that Medigap policies are standardized by plan letter in most states, but companies may charge different premiums for the same standardized benefits. That means shopping carefully is not just acceptable; it is a best practice.

    At Green Insurance Agency in Orange Park, local Medicare conversations often include questions about doctors, prescriptions, travel, household budgets, and whether a client is still working. Those practical details can change whether Plan F, Plan G, Plan N, or another Medicare plan is the better fit.

    When might Plan F be the better choice?

    Plan F may be worth keeping or considering if you are eligible, the premium is competitive, and you value maximum standardized Medigap coverage. For some people, the convenience of having the Part B deductible covered is worth the added monthly cost.

    Plan F may make sense when:

    • You became eligible for Medicare before 2020 and can still access Plan F
    • The premium difference between Plan F and Plan G is small
    • You prefer fewer medical bills after Medicare processes claims
    • You are not comfortable paying the Part B deductible separately
    • You already have Plan F and may not pass underwriting for another plan

    However, Plan F is not automatically the best plan simply because it covers one more benefit category. If its premium is much higher than Plan G, the added cost may not be justified by the deductible coverage.

    This is especially important for people on fixed retirement income. A small monthly premium difference can become meaningful when calculated across a full year and compared with the deductible Plan F covers.

    When might Plan G be the better choice?

    Plan G may be a better choice if you want broad Medigap protection but are willing to pay the Medicare Part B deductible yourself. It is also the primary broad-coverage option for many people newly eligible for Medicare after 2019.

    Plan G may fit well when:

    • You became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020
    • You want coverage similar to Plan F after the Part B deductible
    • The Plan G premium is meaningfully lower than the Plan F premium
    • You want predictable protection from many Original Medicare cost-sharing amounts
    • You prefer to pair Original Medicare with a separate Part D drug plan

    In many real consultations, the f and g comparison becomes a simple math exercise plus a comfort-level discussion. The math looks at premiums and the deductible; the comfort-level discussion asks whether you prefer first-dollar convenience or potential savings.

    Plan G is not perfect for everyone. It does not include drug coverage, routine dental or vision, or long-term custodial care, and it still requires you to keep paying your Medicare Part B premium.

    What questions should you ask before choosing a Medigap Plan?

    Before choosing a Medigap Plan, it helps to slow down and compare how the coverage works in your actual life. A plan that looks best on a chart may not be best once prescriptions, travel, doctors, and budget are considered.

    Ask these questions before enrolling or switching:

    • Am I eligible for Medicare Plan F, or am I limited to newer Medigap options?
    • How much more does Plan F cost per year than Plan G?
    • Does the premium difference exceed the annual Part B deductible?
    • Will I need medical underwriting to switch from Plan F to Plan G?
    • Do my doctors accept Original Medicare?
    • Have I compared a standalone Part D drug plan for my prescriptions?
    • Do I need separate dental, vision, life, or final expense coverage?
    • Could Plan N or another Medicare supplement option fit my budget better?

    The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and Medicare.gov are reliable starting points for standardized benefit information. But those tools do not always explain local carrier pricing, underwriting timing, or how a plan fits a household budget.

    That is where working with a knowledgeable insurance agency can help. A licensed advisor can compare multiple carriers, explain plan limits, and help you avoid mistakes such as dropping coverage too soon or missing an enrollment window.

    What is the simplest way to decide between Plan F and Plan G?

    The simplest way to decide between Plan F and Plan G is to compare eligibility first, total annual cost second, and personal comfort third. If you are not eligible for Plan F, Plan G is often the closest broad-coverage Medigap option.

    If you are eligible for both, compare the annual premium difference against the Medicare Part B deductible. If Plan F costs more than the deductible difference, Plan G may offer better value; if the premium difference is small, Plan F may be reasonable for convenience.

    Also consider future flexibility. If you currently have Plan F and want to move to Plan G, underwriting may matter, so it is wise to review your options before making any cancellation decisions.

    For many beneficiaries, plans f and g are both strong options within the Medicare supplement category. The right choice depends less on the plan letter alone and more on your eligibility date, health situation, location, prescription needs, and budget.

    a Green Insurance Agency advisor in an office reviewing a Medicare plan comparison with a senior client from Orange Park Florida
    a Green Insurance Agency advisor in an office reviewing a Medicare plan comparison with a senior client from Orange Park Florida

    Get local help comparing Medicare Supplement Plan G vs Plan F in Orange Park

    If you are trying to decide between medicare supplement plan g vs plan f, you do not have to sort through eligibility rules, Part B deductible details, and carrier pricing alone. Green Insurance Agency provides local, education-first insurance guidance for individuals, retirees, and caregivers in Orange Park and across Florida.

    Our team can help you compare Medicare Supplement Plan G, Medicare Supplement Plan F, Part D drug plan options, dental and vision coverage, and related insurance needs in a way that fits your doctors, prescriptions, and budget. To take the next step, visit Green Insurance Agency at https://greenins.com and request a personalized Medicare coverage review.

    This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

    Have Medicare Questions? We Have Answers.