Skip to main content
    5/5 (600+ Google Reviews)Certified Medicare Insurance Planner®

    Your Local Medicare Supplement Agency

    Green Insurance Agency helps Northeast Florida seniors compare, enroll in, and re-shop Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans — with rate comparisons across every major carrier, free.

    Get a Free Medigap Review from Our Agency

    Every major Medigap carrier compared—free, no obligation.

    5.0/5(600+ Google Reviews)
    Certified Medicare Insurance Planner® (CMIP®)BBB A+ AccreditedFlorida Licensed Agency

    How Our Supplement Agency Works for You

    1

    Full Medigap Market Review

    We compare Plan G, Plan N, and high-deductible options across every major carrier writing Medigap in Florida.

    2

    Straight Talk on Rates

    We show you current premiums AND each carrier's rate-increase track record, so you're not surprised at renewal.

    3

    Agency-Level Ongoing Service

    Our whole team — not one agent — backs your policy with annual rate reviews, claims help, and re-shopping when prices climb.

    Why Choose an Agency Over a Single Agent or Hotline?

    An agency gives you continuity. Agents retire, move, or change carriers — but Green Insurance Agency has served Orange Park from the same community since 2014, with a full team behind every policy. For Medigap specifically, that means someone is always available to re-shop your rate, handle underwriting questions, and review your coverage every year, decade after decade.

    • A full local team behind your policy — not a single point of failure
    • Independent: every major Florida Medigap carrier compared
    • Rate-increase histories reviewed before you commit to a carrier
    • Underwriting guidance when switching plans after open enrollment
    • Free annual rate reviews — we proactively re-shop rising premiums
    • BBB A+ accredited, 600+ five-star Google reviews

    Medigap Clients on Our Agency

    "I was lucky enough to try Green Insurance Agency after I found out my Medicare Advantage plan was being cancelled. I was impressed with the friendly professional service that I received from the first call."

    Aaron Higginbotham

    Medicare Advantage Plan Change

    "I recently met with Bill Mertens of the Green Insurance Agency. This was the second time I had worked with Bill and I am very happy with the service he provided. He listened to my concerns and we discussed the best Medicare options for me."

    Sharon Noel

    Medicare Enrollment Guidance

    "Last year, after struggling with all of the changes in Medicare Advantage plans, we decided to make an appointment with Bill Green to go over our options. Bill's team explained everything, and we left feeling confident."

    Gail Chapman

    Annual Medicare Review

    Medicare Supplement Agency FAQ

    Put a Local Supplement Agency to Work on Your Medigap Rate